History Teacher Provides a Lesson – But Not One She Intended

Some unlucky souls have already returned to school and we will keep them in our thoughts. Meanwhile, stretch out on the lounger, kick off your shoes, and crack open a cold one while we consider our luckier path, no school till AFTER Labor Day. Let’s contemplate the meaning of school and its role, if any, in receiving an education.

I won’t mention names, but if it’s a comfort to readers, public schools don’t have a monopoly on bad English.

A Teacher’s Letters

My son David’s history teacher, let’s call her Ms. Shale, replied to my note about his grades. Her response was adequate and predictable, except in one regard, her mention of proofreading skills.

English has morphed into Language Arts and the study of English has been left to the Foreign Language department. So unfashionable is it today, that the teacher felt compelled to list in parentheses just what she means.

In regard to History class, David needs to pay specific attention to his proofreading skills (capitalization, puncuation, grammar, verb tenses, etc…).  His written voice can still be very informal (more conversationial than research based).  Going forward, he should put more time into this part of his writing or should look to have another person (parent, friend, sibling, teacher, etc) read over his work and point out these mistakes to him so that he can work on better identifying them himself.


Ms. —-

This makes sense, but I found her letter as informative about her as it was about my son. Readers may have noticed the first time, but even in an age with auto-correct and spell-check features, she made two spelling errors, one in the first sentence and another in the second.

Puncuation and conversationial.

The first is missing a letter and the second has an extra letter. Punc-tu-a-tion and con-ver-sa-tion-al.

Ms. Shale means well and we all make typos. It’s forgivable in most cases, except it violates the purpose of her paragraph. She should mind her letters.

The Real Lesson

The bigger mistake is her belief that a student’s “voice” should be less “informal” and more “research based.” I’m not sure what she means, but I suspect that “research based” means more Latin and Greek words, longer and vague explanations, and a tendency towards useless phrases.

Ms. Shale and her history students would be better served to focus on meaning and clarity. George Orwell said it well, “It [the defense of the English language] has nothing to do with correct grammar and syntax, which are of no importance so long as one makes one’s meaning clear.”

Here’s an example from his popular essay, Politics and the English Language.

I am going to translate a passage of good English into modern English of the worst sort. Here is a well-known verse from Ecclesiastes:

I returned and saw under the sun, that the race is not to the swift, nor the battle to the strong, neither yet bread to the wise, nor yet riches to men of understanding, nor yet favour to men of skill; but time and chance happeneth to them all.

Here it is in modern English:

Objective considerations of contemporary phenomena compel the conclusion that success or failure in competitive activities exhibits no tendency to be commensurate with innate capacity, but that a considerable element of the unpredictable must invariably be taken into account.

The first passage contains 49 words but only 60 syllables, and all of its words are from everyday life, words Ms. Shale would deem informal and discourage. The second contains 38 words of 90 syllables: eighteen of its words are from Latin roots and one from Greek. The first contains six vivid images and the second does not have a “single fresh, arresting phrase, and in spite of its 90 syllables it gives only a shortened version of meaning contained in the first.”

Cut the flab. Get rid of the overblown prose. The modern version is ugly, perverted, and tends away from “concreteness” with its Academic-ese.

Sadly, Ms. Shale is not alone. In my experience, her attitude about writing is common, especially in education circles.

Orwell’s Guidance

Here is Orwell on how to use language as an instrument for expressing thought.

Two qualities are common in modern English, staleness of imagery and lack of precision. Get rid of pretentious diction. Cut meaningless words.

A scrupulous writer, in every sentence that he writes, will ask himself at least four questions.

  1. What am I trying to say?
  2. What words will express it?
  3. What image or idiom will make it clearer?
  4. Is this image fresh enough to have an effect?

Then he’ll probably ask himself two more.

  1. Could I put it more shortly?
  2. Have I said anything that is avoidably ugly?

Look over the next sentence you write, whether it is a text or thesis.

Can you cut words and keep the message? Writers owe it to their readers to say it with less and to make every word count.

I have made this longer than usual because I have not had time to make it shorter. Blaise Pascal

Schooling Versus an Education

Will students learn from Orwell today? That depends on you. Studying Orwell or other great authors is part of the classical model and that is not popular. His writing guidance requires precision, fresh images, clarity, and thought.

Modern English is often not just ugly, but inaccurate. It reflects foolish thoughts which teachers not only encourage, but model in their own writing.Twain on education

Don’t confuse schooling with an education. Ms. Shale wrote and told me about David, but she told me a lot more than what she intended. Learning to write well is about more than grammar.

And that’s a lesson not just for David, but for all of us.

* George Orwell wrote the essay Politics and the English Language in 1946. Every sentence in this 15 page essay instructs and shows just how regimes have gotten away with murder, that writing is not simply the frivolous concern of the professional writer, but that of every person who wishes to think clearly.

** On writing and Orwell, an earlier letter listing Orwell’s six rules for better writing.

Aug 15, 2015


About the Author

Mylinh Shattan is a writer who has lived on three continents, served in the Army, worked in corporate America, and taught in college. She loves adventures, in the world and in the mind. Literature is relevant and learning is a lifelong pursuit, so you might as well have a bit of fun along the way.

Stay Up to Date

Rise above the tedium with the TreeHouseLetter. Always learning with a bit of fun.

Latest Posts

That Teacher, You Know the One

5 Min read Poetry for Emergencies: E.E. Cummings On music: J.S. Bach Commencement speech * * Let's take a moment for teachers. That teacher, you know the one. Because, I have a confession to make. In the lottery of life and learning, if you're lucky then you have one,...

Meditation on Mother’s Day

4 Min read On mandalas On Kansas City On life in the middle * * It's wet and dreary here. And, in spite of the multitude of Mays that I've lived through, I continue to forget how busy this month is with graduations, weddings, parties. And, funerals. What I want to...

Semper Fidelis

4 Min read On patterns On Vietnam and Memorial Day Operation Frequent Wind 1 Book rec * * We had not met before though we had met in other ways, I suppose. We laughed in short order, having teared up moments before. But, first let me say this. The third time is a...

On Poetry, Spring, and Transition

4 Min read Poetry for emergencies 2 Poets Mary Oliver on things Lao Tzu on excess * When I moved from one house to anotherthere were many things I had no roomfor. What does one do? I rented a storagespace. And filled it. Years passed.First lines of "Storage" by Mary...

Small Delight: the Unexpected and the Good

3 Min read 1 Book rec * * I suppose it is the unexpected and the good which sustain us. The package arrived as media mail and I set the used copy on the counter. A week or so later, I began to read it, The Bookshop by Penelope Fitzgerald. What I discovered in its...

Dirtman and Dillard on Signs of the Apocalypse

5 Min read Earthquake Eclipse 1 Essay rec AVAILABLE ON PODCAST SPOTIFY * “And I beheld when he had opened the sixth seal, and, lo, there was a great earthquake; and the sun became black as sackcloth of hair, and the moon became as blood;” Revelation 6:12 * Earthquake...

The Blue Hour

3 Min read Phases of twilight 2 Book recs 5 Regrets of the Dying * It is the darkness which gives that first burst of light its brilliance. * This weekend my daughter returned from spring break. Sitting in the TreeHouse very early that day, I read with a booklight on...


Inoculate yourself against the absurdity of life with a dose of the best ideas and writing. Always learning with a bit of fun.