Why Colleges Are Failing Our Students – Harvard Gets a “D” and Brown Gets an “F”

If you were wondering why college graduates are struggling to find jobs, this explains part of the problem. Many colleges don’t require core subjects like U.S. government/history, literature, and mathematics. Instead, they have replaced the general education curriculum with a “study what you want” philosophy.

It shows.

Almost 62% of college graduates do not know the length of congressional terms and 40% don’t realize the U.S. Constitution establishes separation of powers. One third of grads don’t know which president spearheaded the New Deal and over half don’t know which president played a major role in the Panama Canal. (Source American Council of Trustees and Alumni, GfK surveys)

If you’re a parent considering colleges for your children, take the time to learn about these institutions of “higher learning.”  You will be shocked. You may reconsider spending $40,000 to $50,000 for a big name school. (ACTA Survey link)

The famous Ivy League, for instance, is home to two “Bs,” three “Cs,” two “Ds,” and one “F.”

Brown University, one of the 98 F's received

Brown University, one of the 98 schools that received F’s

In my own state of Connecticut, the only “A” is the United States Coast Guard Academy. The study explains, “All of the United States military service academies require—in addition to a battery of science, mathematics, and engineering classes—courses in literature, expository writing, and United States history.” I will attest to two full years of rigorous core courses as a graduate of the United States Military Academy.

On my state report card,  Yale earns a “D” and Wesleyan an “F” though it’s interesting to note that they have two of the highest graduation rates, 90% and 86%.  Maybe that’s what happens when students don’t study math, history, literature, composition, or economics.

State Report Card, ACTA

State Report Card, ACTA Survey


The grading system is simple.  The study explains the necessity for core subjects and evaluates colleges like this: an A for 6 to 7 subjects required, B for 4 to 5, C for 3, D for 2, and an F for 0 to 1 subjects.

Unlike U.S. News and World Report and other rankings, this survey is the first I’ve seen which grades colleges and universities  on the most important issue, what students learn.  The other systems, by comparison, use selectivity, reputation, and alumni donations.  The key findings in this report revealed a disturbing paradox, among schools receiving an “F” from the survey, the tuition rate is 26% higher than schools receiving an “A.”  “The higher the tuition, the more likely it is that students are left to choose their own “general education.”” (What Will They Learn survey, p. 14 & foreword)

Reasonable people may disagree on what constitutes the general education curriculum and arguably this list should include additional subjects such as philosophy, music, and psychology.  But the survey reflects seven essential subjects needed for a 21st century liberal arts education:  composition, literature, language, U.S. government/history, economics, mathematics, and natural or physical science.

It astonishes me when I look through the list, that students can graduate from higher institutions of learning and reputable schools without completing a history or math class. It’s more disturbing to consider the prices paid for this. A whopping 87% of employers believe colleges need to raise the quality of student achievement and 63% believe grads don’t have the skills to compete.  What’s especially interesting is what graduates themselves think: just 39% of graduates believe college prepared them well to succeed. **

So can students still get a good education at Yale, Brown, or Harvard? That depends on which cafeteria style selections they choose. “No 18 year old, even the brightest, should be given the task of determining which combination of courses comprises a comprehensive education.” (ACTA Survey) Letting them do so results in an odd list of random, unconnected courses.

The Wall Street Journal reported reactions to the survey.  Brown University was not available for comment and Wesleyan declined to comment.  Here is the response from Whittier:

Sean Morris, chairman of the English Department at Whittier, said the survey was superficial. The school has an interdisciplinary approach, so a history curriculum might be wrapped into an art or science course, and composition might be tied to math.

“We don’t mandate every single student take a class in American history…so you may find a senior not knowing the specifics of the New Deal,” he said. “But you will graduate knowing how to think and how to accumulate that knowledge and make connections between things.”  (WSJ, Oct 15)

The success of a representative democracy requires an educated citizenry.  Graduates of these colleges did not have to take U.S. history, though they “might” divine a history curriculum from a class in art or science assuming they sign up for such classes.  But do not worry! because they will know “how to think” and “make connections.”  They could as easily sit down to dinner to discuss the presentation and flavor of the evening meal without food on the table.

Take the time to see for yourself, read the 22 page report, or check on schools to determine what’s required and study their report card. ( report card by college or state here)

There are some interesting selections in the cafeteria line.

As has been noted, many colleges and universities give the appearance of strict requirements, but allow students to satisfy the mandate by choosing from a long eclectic list of courses. This is commonly called a “cafeteria-style” curriculum. The following are a few of the interesting general education classes we found in our research:


• Harvard University: “American Dreams from Scarface to Easy Rider” could count for literature credit.

• University of Denver: First Year Seminars include, “Teen Grrrls and Popular Culture” and “Rock Theatricality: Performing Revolution In Rock n’ Roll.”

• Vassar College: The requirement for a freshman seminar may be met by “America Television Comedy.”

• Hobart and William Smith Colleges: Students can study “Monsters in America” or ” Rock Music and American Masculinities.”

• Chadron State: Among the first year seminars offered is “Wizards and Vampires in Film, TV and Literature.”

(Source: What Will They Learn? Survey 2014-15)


* Key Findings (A survey of core requirements at our nation’s colleges and universities link)

What Will They Learn?™ evaluates every four-year public university with a stated liberal arts mission as well as hundreds of private colleges and universities selected on the basis of size, mission, and regional representation. All schools in the What Will They Learn™ study are regionally-accredited, non-profit institutions. Combined, the 1,098 institutions in the What Will They Learn?™ study enroll over 7.5 million students, more than two-thirds of all students enrolled in four-year liberal arts schools nationwide.

Overall, the results are troubling. The grade tally tells the story:

A 23 (2.1%)

B 389 (35.4%)

C 329 (30.0%)

D 259 (23.6%)

F 98 (8.9%)

Less than half of the schools studied require:

Literature – 37.5%

Foreign Language – 13.1%

U.S. Government or History – 18.3%  

Economics – 3.3%


* Answers to the questions are 6 year term for senators, 2 year terms for representatives; Franklin D. Roosevelt for the New Deal; Theodore Roosevelt for Panama Canal.

** Studies published by the Association of American Colleges and Universities, the Conference Board/Partnership for 21st Century Skills, and the Social Science Research Council have found that:

  • 87% of employers believe that America’s colleges and universities need to raise the quality of student achievement to ensure the United States remains competitive in the global economy.
  • 63% of employers believe that too many recent college graduates do not have the skills they need to succeed in the global economy.
  • Only 39% of recent college graduates say college prepared them very well to succeed in today’s economy.
  • Less than 25% of employers consider the entry-level skills of four-year college graduates to be “excellent.”
  • Over 25% of employers consider the writing skills of four-year graduates “deficient.”
  • 36% of college graduates showed no significant increase in cognitive skills over the four-years they were enrolled full time in college.

Oct 19, 2014


About the Author

Mylinh Shattan is a writer who has lived on three continents, served in the Army, worked in corporate America, and taught in college. She loves adventures, in the world and in the mind. Literature is relevant and learning is a lifelong pursuit, so you might as well have a bit of fun along the way.

Stay Up to Date

Rise above the tedium with the TreeHouseLetter. Always learning with a bit of fun.

Latest Posts

Memorial Day Speech: Because They Lived

9 Min read Memorial Day Speech Transcript and Video, New Canaan Town Hall Honoring seven New Canaan residents Remembering Hailey Hodsden Remembering the MH-60M Black Hawk #490 crew of the 160th SOAR(A) * Honored Resident Photos at this link * VIDEO OF SPEECH - follow...

“We Lived, Felt Dawn, Saw Sunset Glow”

3 Min read Memorial Day Vietnam War Toolbox: Speech writing and public speaking Creative nonfiction / True story Poetry for Emergencies * Last fall I received a request to be the speaker for Memorial Day. I was surprised and then I let it sink in. Me? The Local VFW...

That Teacher, You Know the One

5 Min read Poetry for Emergencies: E.E. Cummings On music: J.S. Bach Commencement speech * * Let's take a moment for teachers. That teacher, you know the one. Because, I have a confession to make. In the lottery of life and learning, if you're lucky then you have one,...

Meditation on Mother’s Day

4 Min read On mandalas On Kansas City On life in the middle * * It's wet and dreary here. And, in spite of the multitude of Mays that I've lived through, I continue to forget how busy this month is with graduations, weddings, parties. And, funerals. What I want to...

Semper Fidelis

4 Min read On patterns On Vietnam and Memorial Day Operation Frequent Wind 1 Book rec * * We had not met before though we had met in other ways, I suppose. We laughed in short order, having teared up moments before. But, first let me say this. The third time is a...

On Poetry, Spring, and Transition

4 Min read Poetry for emergencies 2 Poets Mary Oliver on things Lao Tzu on excess * When I moved from one house to anotherthere were many things I had no roomfor. What does one do? I rented a storagespace. And filled it. Years passed.First lines of "Storage" by Mary...

Small Delight: the Unexpected and the Good

3 Min read 1 Book rec * * I suppose it is the unexpected and the good which sustain us. The package arrived as media mail and I set the used copy on the counter. A week or so later, I began to read it, The Bookshop by Penelope Fitzgerald. What I discovered in its...


Inoculate yourself against the absurdity of life with a dose of the best ideas and writing. Always learning with a bit of fun.