Banned Books Week, Soft Bans & Selective Shelving in Schools

People made over 18,000 attempts to remove books from schools and libraries since 1990, according to the American Library Association  (ALA article link).  Here are the Top Ten Most Frequently Challenged Books (scroll to bottom). My family read six of them, so we have more reading to do to understand the fuss over the other four.  The Top Ten books range from dystopian novel Hunger Games to Captain Underpants and graphic novels like Jeff Smith’s Bone.

Banned books CPT Underpants

Sept. 21 – 27, 2014

And then there is the soft ban on certain books.  Let me explain.

My youngest child begged to read Hunger Games (HG) in third grade because the rest of the family already read the trilogy, myself included.  The Lexile Rating for HG is  810L and this was well in her reading range. The Lexile Framework was developed in 1989 to match readers of all ages with books at their reading level and the developers argued that it is valid and reliable.  I first learned about it from the school.  What’s interesting is I had not used the ratings until this situation and it proved helpful. Critics note flawed ratings and other legitimate concerns, but the Lexile is a tool like any other, to be used along with sound judgment of qualitative factors.

Here is a table with ratings.   (To learn more about the Lexile Framework and find ratings on a particular book, click here.)

The Cat in the HatDr. Seuss260L
Clifford the Big Red DogNorman Bridwell330L
The Very Hungry CaterpillarEric Carle460L
The Giving TreeShel Silverstein530L
The Sun Also RisesErnest Hemingway610L
Charlotte’s WebE. B. White680L
Twilight (novel)Stephenie Meyer720L
A Farewell to ArmsErnest Hemingway730L
Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone (novel)J. K. Rowling880L
A Tale of Two CitiesCharles Dickens990L
The HobbitJ. R. R. Tolkien1000L
Gone with the WindMargaret Mitchell1100L
A Brief History of TimeStephen Hawking1290L

Example of Lexile Ratings

Third grade may seem young for Hunger Games, but my daughter Laura was ready.  I read Tom Sawyer (950L) to her that year and she read Ranger’s Apprentice (920L) on her own.  At the time, I was reading Rosemary Sutcliff’s Iliad, Black Ships Before Troy (1300L) to her.

Laura came home upset from school one day.  The teacher saw her reading HG during Independent Reading time and called her over, explaining that she was not allowed to read it in school.

She was embarrassed and felt like a criminal.

I wrote the teacher that evening.

 Good morning Ms. Teacher,

 Laura told me what happened today and I was surprised to learn she is not allowed to read her book at school.   Her siblings, my husband and I have read the Collins trilogy and Laura is now reading the second book.   I see this as a read for more engaged readers in grade school and not allowing her to do so is censorship of a kind.   HG has a Lexile rating of 810 which is more than suitable for 10 year olds or 4th graders and Laura reads at that level.

Please let me know why it is banned at School. We are reading Homer’s Iliad, the illustrated work by Sutcliffe and if carnage and pillage are of concern, then the School may have to ban the Greek myths.  Collins based her book on the Greek myth of the Minotaur and the youth tributes sent annually to their death in its labyrinth.

I appreciate that you are enforcing policy and perhaps the district, the principal or the librarian compiled the list. You are welcome to pass this Email along.  As we are a family of voracious readers, I would like to have the list of books considered ‘inappropriate’ or banned at School X.

Thank you,

MyLinh Shattan

“Withholding information is the essence of tyranny. Control of the flow of information is the tool of the dictatorship.”
― Bruce Coville (author’s page on

The teacher wrote back the next morning, stating she referred my letter to the principal. She said my daughter “displayed great fluency and comprehension” in her reading, but she did not mention her decision, saying instead that she “hoped Dr. Principal could answer my questions” about HG.  Later, Dr. Principal saw me at a school function and asked if I received her phone message.  I had not.

Dr. Principal checked with Ms. Librarian who said Hunger Games was not shelved in the elementary school. She explained that the district does not ban books. It is available in the Middle School, but students must have parent approval before borrowing it.

I expressed surprise that Laura was the only student reading HG. Given the Lexile Rating, surely there were older children reading it in the school.  Dr. Principal shifted weight from one foot to the other, pausing, then said the librarians shelve what is appropriate for the school and grade level.  I volunteered in the library and there were multiple copies of Harry Potter which has a higher rating (880L), so it wasn’t done by Lexile; someone decided it was inappropriate for elementary school.

I asked Dr. Principal about Independent Reading time, how until now, Laura chose her own books, read what she wanted. She had an answer for that too.  Independent Reading time was for books from the school, student choice of course. Dr. Principal said she didn’t have a problem with Laura reading HG, but not in class.  Her concern for other students came up, as well as age appropriate material in the classroom.   I asked just when Laura could read HG and the principal said she could do so at recess or on the bus.

I explained to my daughter that she was allowed to read HG at school, but there were restrictions.

So Laura sat on the blacktop at recess and read.  And she read on the bus.  And she finished the trilogy.

Words are powerful.  But actions often speak louder than words. The principal said the district doesn’t ban books, yet the librarians shelve ‘age appropriate’ books; I call it selective shelving.

Or banned books.

You decide.

And here is the ALA press release of the Top Ten Banned Books.  Drumroll please.
Many bookstores, schools and libraries celebrating Banned Books Week will showcase selections from the ALA OIF’s Top Ten Most Frequently Challenged Books of 2013. The list is released each spring and provides a snapshot of book removal attempts in the U.S. The Top Ten Most Frequently Challenged Books of 2013 reflects a range of themes and consists of the following titles:
  1. “Captain Underpants” (series), by Dav Pilkey.
    Reasons: Offensive language, unsuited for age group, violence
  2. “The Bluest Eye,” by Toni Morrison
    Reasons: Offensive language, sexually explicit, unsuited to age group, violence
  3. “The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian,” by Sherman Alexie.|
    Reasons: Drugs/alcohol/smoking, offensive language, racism, sexually explicit, unsuited for age group
  4. “Fifty Shades of Grey,” by E. L. James.
    Reasons: Nudity, offensive language, religious viewpoint, sexually explicit, unsuited to age group
  5. “The Hunger Games,” by Suzanne Collins
    Reasons: Religious viewpoint, unsuited to age group
  6. “A Bad Boy Can Be Good for A Girl,” by Tanya Lee Stone
    Reasons: Drugs/alcohol/smoking, nudity, offensive language, sexually explicit
  7. “Looking for Alaska,” by John Green.
    Reasons: Drugs/alcohol/smoking, sexually explicit, unsuited to age group
  8. “The Perks of Being a Wallflower,” by Stephen Chbosky
    Reasons: Drugs/alcohol/smoking, homosexuality, sexually explicit, unsuited to age group
  9. “Bless Me Ultima,” by Rudolfo Anaya
    Reasons: Occult/Satanism, offensive language, religious viewpoint, sexually explicit
  10. “Bone” (series), by Jeff Smith
    Reasons: Political viewpoint, racism, violence

Sep 25, 2014


About the Author

Mylinh Shattan is a writer who has lived on three continents, served in the Army, worked in corporate America, and taught in college. She loves adventures, in the world and in the mind. Literature is relevant and learning is a lifelong pursuit, so you might as well have a bit of fun along the way.

Stay Up to Date

Rise above the tedium with the TreeHouseLetter. Always learning with a bit of fun.

Latest Posts

That Teacher, You Know the One

5 Min read Poetry for Emergencies: E.E. Cummings On music: J.S. Bach Commencement speech * * Let's take a moment for teachers. That teacher, you know the one. Because, I have a confession to make. In the lottery of life and learning, if you're lucky then you have one,...

Meditation on Mother’s Day

4 Min read On mandalas On Kansas City On life in the middle * * It's wet and dreary here. And, in spite of the multitude of Mays that I've lived through, I continue to forget how busy this month is with graduations, weddings, parties. And, funerals. What I want to...

Semper Fidelis

4 Min read On patterns On Vietnam and Memorial Day Operation Frequent Wind 1 Book rec * * We had not met before though we had met in other ways, I suppose. We laughed in short order, having teared up moments before. But, first let me say this. The third time is a...

On Poetry, Spring, and Transition

4 Min read Poetry for emergencies 2 Poets Mary Oliver on things Lao Tzu on excess * When I moved from one house to anotherthere were many things I had no roomfor. What does one do? I rented a storagespace. And filled it. Years passed.First lines of "Storage" by Mary...

Small Delight: the Unexpected and the Good

3 Min read 1 Book rec * * I suppose it is the unexpected and the good which sustain us. The package arrived as media mail and I set the used copy on the counter. A week or so later, I began to read it, The Bookshop by Penelope Fitzgerald. What I discovered in its...

Dirtman and Dillard on Signs of the Apocalypse

5 Min read Earthquake Eclipse 1 Essay rec AVAILABLE ON PODCAST SPOTIFY * “And I beheld when he had opened the sixth seal, and, lo, there was a great earthquake; and the sun became black as sackcloth of hair, and the moon became as blood;” Revelation 6:12 * Earthquake...

The Blue Hour

3 Min read Phases of twilight 2 Book recs 5 Regrets of the Dying * It is the darkness which gives that first burst of light its brilliance. * This weekend my daughter returned from spring break. Sitting in the TreeHouse very early that day, I read with a booklight on...


Inoculate yourself against the absurdity of life with a dose of the best ideas and writing. Always learning with a bit of fun.